Score: 10

"Average Man, Reel Big Fish."

submission: Average Man

date: June 17, 2009

Artist.

Score: 0

"Don't cram the portal."

submission: animation

date: September 27, 2008

Test animation yourself, don't submit it to us.

Score: 2

"Good idea, but..."

submission: Space Invaders v1.0

date: September 27, 2008

A few things stack against it.

It looks great, but the whole thing looks confusing. There are two ships on-screen, and the enemies don't disappear when hit.

Fix it up and it should be fine.

Score: 10

"Beautiful."

submission: :the Composer:

date: December 21, 2007

Simply a work of art. The story was amazing. Words don't always make a story great, but every element combines and meshes to make a great mix of beauty and simplicity that touches the hearts of everyone.

I have only one criticism. If you could, could you make the people a bit meatier? I understand if it's your style, but I always felt like they were too skinny or thin.

Of course, that's just nit picking. The whole thing was beautiful and inspiring, as well as heartwarming.

Score: 8

"Good work!"

submission: Dad's at Work

date: December 21, 2007

Very good. The animations were great, but the graphics could use a good notch up.

Score: 6

"Work on the sound quality."

submission: Pico's Rush to PicoDay

date: December 21, 2007

My ears were fucking bleeding from that.

Score: 3

"Not good at all."

submission: Pico Vs. Zico

date: December 21, 2007

I'm sorry, but I have to criticize this.

The graphics were lackluster, and the animations were definitely not top-notch. The movie is WAYYY too short, and the whole thing needs a little ramping up.

I'm sure you can do better, but please work harder. I encourage your support for Pico day, however, and the evil twin concept can really be moved farther. If you improved the story and everything I mentioned, it would be a masterpiece. I understand the file loss, but you should attempt to further your ability in more meaty Flashes.

Score: 7

"Nice animation, but..."

submission: Super MarioWars (Trailer)

date: December 11, 2007

Work on the storyline.

I don't wanna watch a 5 minute long movie about senseless violence (although it IS fun) I think a little story at least would make it better.

Score: 10

"Very informative!"

submission: Newgrounds Information

date: December 8, 2007

I hope this gets an award and front page. If it doesn't, then it loses its whole purpose, which is to help new users and inform people of old Newgrounds.

Score: 9

"Excellent work!"

submission: DQ Mania Part 1

date: December 8, 2007

Very well done, my friend. Very well done.

One question though... Can I be in the next one?